The Top 10 Milkshake Flavors With Creative Mix-in Inspiration

The Top 10 Milkshake Flavors With Creative Mix-in Inspiration

Milkshakes, the classic treat that never goes out of style. Whether you prefer a traditional flavor or enjoy experimenting with new combinations, there is a milkshake flavor out there to satisfy everyone’s cravings. In this list, we explore the top 10 milkshake flavors with creative mix-in ideas. We’ve provided a brief description of each flavor and some fun ideas on how you could elevate each concept.

1. Classic Vanilla

A timeless favorite, the classic vanilla milkshake is a smooth and creamy blend of vanilla ice cream and milk. Its simplicity allows the pure essence of vanilla to shine through. Vanilla milkshakes are often paired with a dollop of whipped cream and sprinkles. We suggest adding Vanilla Cake Pieces or Cookie Pieces with a buttercream flavor base to really impress the vanilla aficionados.


2. Chocoholics Dream

Oh, the velvety goodness of a chocolate milkshake. Made with chocolate ice cream, milk, and chocolate syrup or cocoa powder, this rich flavor is staple for all chocoholics out there. A well-balanced textured cookie variegate can elevate this milkshake to a whole new level of decadence. Imagine the addition of smooth Truffles or Baked Brownies to push the traditional chocolate buffs over the ledge.


3. Sensational Strawberry

For those who prefer fruit forward, the strawberry milkshake is a great choice. Packed with fresh strawberries, strawberry ice cream, and milk, this milkshake offers a perfectly balanced sweet and tangy taste. Try a variety with Pound Cake Pieces, or Shortcake Crunch to add texture and a bit of excitement to the usual.


4. Cookies and Cream Dream

Indulge your sweet tooth with a cookies and cream milkshake. This concoction often features crushed chocolate sandwich cookies mixed with creamy vanilla ice cream and milk. The resulting blend is a heavenly mixture of crunchy cookie pieces in luscious ice cream. We have lots of fun items that could elevate this concept including Popping Cookies and Cream Clusters, but a favorite is the creamy variegate with Chocolate Cookie Pieces offering a simple way to add texture and flavor with one SKU.


5. Salted Caramel

For a more indulgent milkshake experience, try the salted caramel flavor. This milkshake offers a smooth and buttery taste. Optional toppings and mix in’s like Caramel Drizzle or Caramel Pralined Pretzels can take it to the next level.


6. Mint Chocolate

Not much better than a refreshing mint milkshake. This flavor features a harmonious combination of mint chocolate chip ice cream and milk, and would be fantastic with a Mint Chocolate Bark or Coated Rice Crisp to provide a new experience on a classic.


7. Peanut Butter Paradise

Peanut butter lovers rejoice! A peanut butter milkshake is a sweet and nutty delight. Made with creamy peanut butter, vanilla ice cream, and milk, this milkshake offers a thick and creamy texture with a rich peanut butter taste. For some extra pizzazz, you can add Praline Peanuts or Pretzel, heck why not add some Fudge Clusters and Chocolate Sauce.


8. Fruity Tropical Paradise

Escape to an island paradise with a tropical fruit milkshake. This milkshake blends tropical fruits like mango, pineapple, or banana with vanilla ice cream and milk. Add a Popping Passion Fruit Clusters a swirl of Mango Passionfruit and the result is a fruity, tropical explosion of flavors that will transport you to a crisp, clear, sunny day on the beach.


9. S’mores Spectacular

Bring the campfire to your milkshake with a S’mores treat. This creative shake combines chocolate ice cream, a marshmallow variegate with graham cookies and milk to recreate the nostalgic taste of a classic S’mores treat. A couple fun variations would include a different “cookie” pieces such as a Chocolate Cookie in place of a graham or really surprise your guests with a Strawberry Base with a toasted Marshmallow Sauce and Fudge Coated Shortbread Pieces.


10. Coffee Infusion

And for those that need a pick me up, a coffee-infused milkshake is just the thing. This flavor combines coffee ice cream or brewed coffee, milk, and a touch of sweetness for a creamy and caffeinated delight. Optional mix-ins like coated Espresso Sprinkles or Coffee Toffee make this one tough to refuse. Top it with whipped cream and a light dusting of sprinkles to perfect this milkshake


From the classic simplicity of vanilla to the adventurous combination of S’mores, these top milkshake flavors cater to a variety of tastes and preferences. Whether you’re craving something fruity, chocolaty, or nutty, there is a milkshake flavor on this list waiting to tempt your taste buds.

As for our Editors Choice, based on her love of the Florida Keys and the inspiration of a Key Lime Colada, she chose a Key Lime Pie Milkshake and we now know why.  This blend of vanilla ice cream, a tart Key Lime Sauce blended with Graham Pieces and topped with whipped cream, Coconut and Key Lime Flavored Popping Clusters and Graham Pieces. It’s the perfect blend of sweet and tart, and will easily transport you to the laid back, eclectic vibe of Key West.

So go ahead, pick your favorite and treat yourself to the ultimate milkshake experience!

+1214.631.3669 | 800.733.3589

Send an Email

Mon- Fri 8:30 am - 5 pm

Contact Form Cutout

Let us be Your Secret Ingredient.

Let us develop custom-made inclusions just for you. Inquire here and one of our team members will be in touch with you shortly; we look forward to creating something extraordinary together!